Cheapest Places to Stay in Key West in 2025

Author: Nathan Knight

Planning a trip to Key West on a budget? Discover the top affordable accommodations that offer comfort and convenience without breaking the bank. From charming guesthouses to budget-friendly motels, explore the best options for cost-effective stays in Key West. Whether you’re seeking proximity to popular attractions or a peaceful retreat, our curated list of the cheapest places to stay in Key West ensures you enjoy the island’s vibrant culture and stunning scenery without overspending. Start planning your affordable Key West getaway today!

The 10 Most Affordable Hotels in Key West

1. Seashell Motel: Best for Backpackers and Solo Travelers

   • Location: Old Town Key West
   • Description: Offers both private rooms and dormitory-style accommodations, making it a budget-friendly option for travelers.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $120 per night for private rooms
   • Best Months for This Rate: September
   • Phone: (305) 296-5719
   • Website: seashellmotel.com

2. Southwinds Motel: Affordable Comfort In Old Town Key West

   • Location: Old Town Key West
   • Description: Located just steps from the beach and Duval Street, Southwinds Motel offers clean rooms, three outdoor pools, and complimentary continental breakfast.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $135 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: August to September
   • Phone: (305) 296-2215
   • Website: southwindsmotel.com

3. Ibis Bay Beach Resort, Key West

   • Location: North Roosevelt Boulevard
   • Description: This resort features a private beach, an outdoor pool, and on-site dining. Rooms are decorated in a retro style, providing a unique Key West experience.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $147 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: July to September
   • Phone: (305) 296-1043
   • Website: ibisbayresort.com

4. Courtney’s Place Historic Cottages & Inns: Historic Charm On A Budget

   • Location: Old Town Key West
   • Description: Historic cottages offering a quaint stay with modern amenities, including a pool and complimentary breakfast.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $157 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: August
   • Phone: (305) 294-3480
   • Website: courtneysplacekeywest.com

5. Authors Key West Guesthouse, Key West

   • Location: The Meadows
   • Description: A cozy guesthouse named after famous authors, featuring a pool and complimentary breakfast.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $175 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: September
   • Phone: (305) 294-7381
   • Website: authorskeywest.com

6. The Caribbean House, Key West

   • Location: Truman Annex
   • Description: A vibrant guesthouse offering colorful rooms and a tropical atmosphere, just steps from Duval Street.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $175 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: September
   • Phone: (305) 296-0999
   • Website: caribbeanhousekw.com

7. The Garden House, Key West

   • Location: Old Town North of Truman
   • Description: A charming guesthouse with a pool, offering a peaceful retreat close to the action.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $180 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: July to August
   • Phone: (305) 296-5368
   • Website: gardenhousekeywest.com

8. The Grand Guesthouse, Key West

   • Location: Old Town Key West
   • Description: A charming guesthouse offering personalized service, comfortable rooms, and a complimentary breakfast. It’s within walking distance of major attractions.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $204 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: September
   • Phone: (305) 294-0590
   • Website: thegrandguesthouse.com

9. Heron House – The Most Affordable Adults Only Hotel In Key West

   • Location: Old Town Key West
   • Description: An adult-only guesthouse featuring a rooftop terrace, outdoor pool, and complimentary breakfast. It’s praised for its central location and friendly staff.
   • Approximate Rate: Starting at $209 per night
   • Best Months for This Rate: August to September
   • Phone: (305) 294-9227
   • Website: heronhouse.com

10. Hampton Inn, Key West

    • Location: New Town
    • Description: Offers modern amenities, including a fitness center, outdoor pool, and free breakfast. It’s a short drive from Old Town attractions.
    • Approximate Rate: Starting at $219 per night
    • Best Months for This Rate: July to August
    • Phone: (305) 296-3500
    • Website: hilton.com

cheapest hotels in key west 2025

When Is the Best Time to Find Cheap Hotel Rates in Key West?

Please note that hotel rates fluctuate based on demand, special events, and availability. It’s advisable to book well in advance and check multiple sources to secure the best rates. The best time to visit Key West for budget-conscious travelers is during the off-season, particularly from late summer through mid-October. During this period, the island experiences fewer crowds, allowing you to enjoy a more relaxed and authentic Key West experience. Hotel rates and travel costs are significantly lower compared to the peak winter season, making it an ideal time for those looking to save money. While the weather is warm and tropical, occasional rain showers and the possibility of hurricanes are factors to consider. However, with flexible travel plans and careful monitoring of forecasts, visiting during this time can provide an affordable and enjoyable getaway. Take advantage of discounted rates on accommodations and activities while soaking in the laid-back vibe of this tropical paradise.

Next Key West Tip: Best Ways To Get Around: Golf carts, taxis, ride-shares & more